Training a stubborn dog can feel frustrating, exhausting, and sometimes even hopeless. You may find yourself repeating commands endlessly, offering treats that go ignored, or wondering if your dog is simply unwilling to learn. The truth is, stubborn dogs are not bad dogs, and they are not untrainable. What they need is a different approach, one that matches their personality, motivation, and learning style.
In this guide, you will learn exactly how to train a stubborn dog using proven, humane, and effective techniques. Whether your dog ignores commands, refuses to cooperate, or seems to have a mind of their own, this guide will help you understand why your dog behaves this way and how to turn resistance into reliable obedience.
What “Stubborn” Really Means in Dogs?
Before jumping into training methods, it is important to understand what stubbornness actually looks like in dogs. Most dogs labeled as stubborn are not trying to disobey out of spite. Instead, their behavior is often rooted in one or more of the following factors:
- Strong independence or intelligence
- High prey drive or distractions
- Lack of clear communication from the owner
- Inconsistent training or boundaries
- Low motivation or poor reward choices
- Past negative training experiences
Some breeds are also known for being more independent thinkers. Breeds such as Huskies, Beagles, Dachshunds, Shiba Inus, and Terriers are often labeled stubborn because they were bred to make decisions on their own rather than follow constant human direction. Understanding that stubbornness is often independence, confusion, or lack of motivation can completely change how you approach training.
Common Reasons Why Dogs Appear Stubborn
1. Lack of Proper Motivation
Dogs will repeat behaviors that benefit them. If the reward is not valuable enough, your dog may simply choose not to comply. Some dogs are food-motivated, others prefer toys, praise, or play.
2. Inconsistent Training
If commands change, rules are enforced sometimes but not always, or different family members train differently, your dog may not understand what is expected.
3. Too Much Freedom Too Soon
Allowing a dog full access to the house, yard, or off-leash time before training is solid can reinforce ignoring commands.
4. Overuse of Repetition
Repeating commands over and over teaches the dog that listening the first time is optional.
5. Stress, Fear, or Past Trauma
Dogs trained with punishment-based methods may shut down, resist, or appear stubborn due to fear or confusion.
The Right Mindset for Training a Stubborn Dog
Training a stubborn dog starts with adjusting your mindset. Patience, consistency, and calm leadership are essential. Yelling, physical punishment, or frustration will only worsen resistance.
Key principles to remember:
- Your dog is always learning, even when not actively training
- Calm confidence is more effective than force
- Training is about communication, not control
- Progress may be slow, but consistency always pays off
Think of training as teaching a language your dog does not yet speak fluently.
How to Train a Stubborn Dog: A Step-by-Step Guide
Step 1: Build a Strong Bond First
A dog that trusts and respects you will be far more willing to cooperate.
Ways to strengthen your bond:
- Spend quality time together daily
- Play interactive games like tug or fetch
- Hand-feed meals occasionally
- Train in short, positive sessions
- Avoid harsh corrections
Bonding creates a foundation where your dog wants to engage with you rather than resist you.
Step 2: Identify What Motivates Your Dog
Stubborn dogs are often selective about rewards. Finding the right motivator is critical.
Common motivators include:
- High-value treats (chicken, cheese, liver)
- Favorite toys
- Praise and affection
- Playtime or freedom
Test different rewards and observe which ones your dog responds to most enthusiastically. Use the highest-value rewards for the most difficult behaviors.
Step 3: Keep Training Sessions Short and Focused
Stubborn dogs often lose interest quickly. Long sessions lead to frustration for both of you.
Ideal training sessions:
- 5 to 10 minutes at a time
- 2 to 4 sessions per day
- End on a success
- Train when your dog is calm and slightly hungry
Short sessions maintain focus and prevent burnout.
Step 4: Start with Basic Commands and Master Them Fully
Do not rush advanced training before basics are solid.
Essential commands to focus on:
- Sit
- Down
- Stay
- Come
- Leave it
- Heel
Train in a low-distraction environment first, such as indoors, before gradually adding distractions.
Step 5: Use Clear and Consistent Commands
Dogs do not understand language the way humans do. Consistency is crucial.
Best practices:
- Use the same word for each command
- Say the command once
- Use a calm, firm tone
- Avoid repeating commands
If your dog does not respond, reset the situation instead of repeating yourself.
Step 6: Stop Repeating Commands
Repeating commands teaches your dog that obedience is optional.
Instead:
- Say the command once
- Wait briefly
- If your dog ignores it, guide them into the correct behavior or reset and try again
This teaches your dog that listening the first time matters.
Step 7: Control the Environment to Set Your Dog Up for Success
Management is just as important as training.
Examples:
- Use a leash indoors if needed
- Limit access to distractions
- Remove tempting objects during training
- Practice recall in fenced areas first
Reducing distractions helps your dog focus and succeed.
Step 8: Reward Immediately and Clearly
Timing is everything in dog training.
- Reward within 1 to 2 seconds of correct behavior
- Mark good behavior with a word like “yes”
- Be enthusiastic but calm
Delayed rewards confuse dogs and weaken learning.
Step 9: Be Consistent with Rules and Boundaries
Stubborn dogs thrive on clarity.
Examples:
- If jumping is not allowed, it is never allowed
- If furniture access is restricted, it must always be restricted
- Everyone in the household must follow the same rules
Inconsistency creates confusion and resistance.
Step 10: Avoid Punishment-Based Training
Punishment may stop behavior temporarily but often increases stubbornness, fear, or aggression.
Problems with punishment:
- Damages trust
- Increases stress
- Reduces willingness to try
- Suppresses behavior without teaching alternatives
Positive reinforcement builds long-term reliability and confidence.
Step 11: Turn Training into a Game
Many stubborn dogs respond better when training feels fun rather than forced.
Ideas:
- Use hide-and-seek for recall training
- Teach tricks like spin or paw
- Use obstacle courses
- Incorporate play as a reward
When training is enjoyable, resistance decreases.
Step 12: Increase Difficulty Gradually
Do not expect perfect behavior immediately in distracting environments.
Progression should look like:
- Indoors with no distractions
- Indoors with mild distractions
- Outdoors in quiet areas
- Busy environments
Rushing this process often leads to setbacks.
Step 13: Address Specific Stubborn Behaviors
Ignoring Recall
- Never punish a dog for coming late
- Use high-value rewards
- Practice daily in safe areas
Pulling on the Leash
- Stop walking when pulling occurs
- Reward loose leash walking
- Change direction frequently
Refusing to Sit or Stay
- Reduce distractions
- Increase reward value
- Shorten duration
Selective Listening
- Ensure commands are well-trained
- Avoid overusing commands
- Reinforce reliability daily
Step 14: Provide Enough Mental and Physical Exercise
A bored dog is far more likely to resist training.
Mental stimulation ideas:
- Puzzle toys
- Scent games
- Training new tricks
- Food-dispensing toys
Physical exercise:
- Daily walks
- Play sessions
- Breed-appropriate activities
A tired mind learns better than a restless one.
Step 15: Be Patient and Track Progress
Training a stubborn dog is a marathon, not a sprint.
Tips:
- Celebrate small improvements
- Keep a training journal
- Avoid comparing your dog to others
- Focus on progress, not perfection
Consistency over time always produces results.
When to Consider Professional Help
If your dog shows extreme resistance, aggression, or anxiety, a professional trainer or behaviorist can help.
Seek help if:
- Training leads to fear or shutdown
- Aggression is present
- No progress after consistent effort
- Safety is a concern
Choose trainers who use positive, science-based methods.
Final Thought
Stubborn dogs are often intelligent, independent, and full of personality. With the right approach, these traits can become strengths rather than challenges. Training a stubborn dog requires patience, creativity, and consistency, but the reward is a deeply bonded, reliable, and confident companion.
Remember, your dog is not giving you a hard time. They are having a hard time understanding what works best for them. When you meet your dog where they are and guide them with clarity and kindness, even the most stubborn dog can learn to listen, cooperate, and thrive.
FAQ’s
Why is my dog so stubborn?
Most dogs labeled as stubborn are actually independent, easily distracted, or unclear about what you want. Breed traits, lack of motivation, inconsistent training, and environmental distractions are common reasons.
Can a stubborn dog be trained?
Yes. Stubborn dogs can be trained effectively with consistent, positive reinforcement methods. The key is using the right motivation, clear communication, and structured training sessions.
How long does it take to train a stubborn dog?
Training time varies based on the dog’s age, breed, and past experiences. With consistent training, most dogs show noticeable improvement within 2 to 6 weeks. Full reliability may take a few months.
What is the best way to train a stubborn dog?
The best way is reward-based training using high-value treats, short sessions, consistent commands, and gradual exposure to distractions. Avoid punishment-based methods as they can increase resistance.
How do I get my stubborn dog to listen to me?
Use clear, single-word commands, reward immediate compliance, keep training sessions short, and avoid repeating commands. Consistency and leadership through calm confidence also help.
Should I punish my dog for not listening?
No. Punishment can increase fear and resistance, and damage trust. Instead, redirect your dog to the correct behavior and reward them when they follow the command.
What if my dog ignores recall?
Practice recall in a safe, low-distraction area first. Use high-value rewards, avoid calling your dog only for negative events, and make coming to you the most rewarding option.
Can stubborn dogs be trained without treats?
Yes, but you need to find a reward your dog values more, such as toys, play, or praise. Treats are helpful, especially early in training, but not the only option.
How do I train a stubborn dog to walk on a leash?
Use a front-clip harness or no-pull harness, stop walking when your dog pulls, reward loose leash walking, and change directions frequently to keep your dog focused.
Also Read: